HELOC vs. cash-out refinance in NYC
In one line: a HELOC adds a reusable credit line secured by your home and usually leaves your first mortgage alone. A cash-out refinance replaces your first mortgage with a bigger one and pays you the difference. In New York City, both involve recording a mortgage, so the recording tax belongs in the comparison.
Below: the structure side by side, then the New York tax rules from official sources, then what a few New York lenders say about their own products on their public pages. We don’t quote rates, and nothing here is a recommendation.
Side by side
| HELOC | Cash-out refinance | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An “open-end” line of credit “that allows you to borrow repeatedly against your home equity” (CFPB) | You “replace your existing mortgage with a bigger mortgage and take the difference in cash” (CFPB) |
| Your first mortgage | Stays in place if you have one; CFPB says the HELOC would be a second mortgage you pay in addition to it | Paid off and replaced by the new loan |
| How you get money | Draw as needed during the draw period, then repay; CFPB says payments are often significantly higher once repayment starts | One payout at closing |
| Rate | CFPB: HELOCs “usually have a variable interest rate” | Set by the new mortgage’s terms; CFPB says to weigh it carefully, “especially if it is higher than the interest rate on your current mortgage” |
| Closing costs | Vary by lender; see the lender table below | CFPB: “Often, you have to pay closing costs” |
| Which costs less | CFPB: “Depending on the terms a cash out refinance may be more or less expensive than a HELOC” | Same |
| If you can’t pay | Your home is the collateral for both. CFPB on HELOCs: “you could lose your home” | Same |
New York mortgage recording tax, for each
Official sources, read 2026-11-05. This is how the rules read, not a statement of what you’d owe.
| Question | HELOC | Cash-out refinance | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Is tax charged when the mortgage is recorded? | NYC DOF: “A tax is charged when mortgages for property in New York City are recorded.” A HELOC is secured by a mortgage; the credit line rows below explain how that kind of mortgage is taxed. | Yes. DOF’s 2024 MRT report: “In most cases, the refinancing of an existing mortgage is also subject to the tax.” | DOF MRT page; DOF 2024 MRT report |
| Combined State + City rates DOF lists | Under $500,000: 2.050%. $500,000 or more, residential: 2.175%. $500,000 or more, commercial: 2.800%. | Same schedule | DOF 2024 MRT report |
| What amount is taxed? | If the mortgage is a credit line mortgage, the NYS Tax Department says the tax “is based on the maximum principal amount that may be secured by the mortgage.” For a revolving line, that’s generally the credit limit. | The new mortgage. DOF’s report says refinancing is taxed “in most cases.” How much of the new loan is taxed in your refinance isn’t stated on the pages we read; ask your lender and check ACRIS. | NYS Tax credit-line bulletin, updated March 30, 2026; TB-MR-580 |
| Tax on later draws? | For a credit line mortgage on a one- to six-family owner-occupied home, the bulletin says that once tax is paid on the maximum, “no further tax is payable when advances or re-advances are made,” if they go to the original borrowers named in the recorded mortgage (Tax Law section 253-b, as the bulletin and TSB-M-95(4)R summarize it). | Not applicable (no draws) | NYS Tax credit-line bulletin; TSB-M-95(4)R |
| Co-op apartments | DOF’s report: mortgages on individual co-op apartments “do not incur liability under the mortgage recording tax.” | Same | DOF 2024 MRT report |
| Where it’s recorded | Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens: ACRIS. Staten Island: in person at the Richmond County Clerk’s Office, which also collects the tax. | Same | DOF MRT page |
| Transfer tax? | Separate tax, on “sales, grants, assignments, transfers or surrenders of real property.” Neither loan is a sale. | Same | DOF RPTT page |
What we are not saying: none of these official pages use the word “HELOC.” A product called a HELOC fits the credit line mortgage rules only if the recorded mortgage meets that definition, which is fact-specific. So we are not stating a rule that HELOCs in New York carry no mortgage tax, and we aren’t saying what any HELOC or refinance owes. Some lenders pay the tax for you under their own conditions (next section). That changes who pays at closing, not whether the tax applies.
What some New York lenders say on their public pages
These are the lenders’ own product descriptions, read on their public websites on 2026-11-05 and listed alphabetically. They aren’t recommendations, rankings or offers, and they aren’t every lender. We have no relationship with any of them, and no one paid to be listed. Terms change often. We leave out all rates, APRs, payment examples and dollar amounts. Read the lender’s own page and disclosures for those.
| Lender (alphabetical) | Product described | Rate type, in the lender’s words | Closing costs and NY mortgage tax: the lender’s claim and conditions it states | Other conditions it states | Source, retrieved |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First New York Federal Credit Union | HELOC (variable and fixed) | “Variable and fixed rates are available” | Headline: “Pay no closing costs” and “Pay no NYS mortgage tax.” Its footnotes say closing costs “including New York State Mortgage Tax” that it pays are “charged back and added to the loan’s payoff” if the HELOC is paid and closed within three years. On its fixed-rate HELOC tables it says “New York State Mortgage Tax is required and paid by the borrower.” | Must be a primary residence; minimum advance at closing; title insurance may be required and paid by the borrower. Page lists an Albany, NY address; whether it lends on NYC homes isn’t stated there. | https://firstnewyork.org/home-equity/ (2026-11-05) |
| FourLeaf Federal Credit Union | HELOC, 1st or 2nd lien | Not described in words on this page | Its footnote: closing costs “for the first $500,000 will be paid by FourLeaf,” but “must be repaid” if the HELOC is closed within the first 36 months; above that, the borrower pays “mortgage tax and title insurance costs on the loan value portion over $500,000.” The page body gives a different no-closing-cost line size than the footnote; check with the lender. | 1st lien if you own the home outright or use part of the HELOC to pay off your mortgage | https://www.fourleaffcu.com/personal/home-equity-loan-1st-lien-position/ (2026-11-05) |
| FourLeaf Federal Credit Union | Cash-out refinance (educational page) | Fixed or adjustable mortgage options | Says some lenders offer “no-closing cost loans” that cover upfront closing costs “but charge a higher interest rate over the lifespan of the loan,” and that full closing costs are listed in the loan estimate | You borrow “more than they owe on the current loan and the lender pays the difference out” | https://www.fourleaffcu.com/learning-center/mortgage-loans/refinancing-your-mortgage/ (2026-11-05) |
| Municipal Credit Union | HELOC | Introductory period, then “converts to a variable rate” | Covered closing costs paid by MCU if you take a minimum initial advance and keep the line open at least 36 months; certain third-party fees must be repaid if closed sooner. For some promotions, you may have MCU pay “mortgage recording fees and state mortgage transfer taxes” (its wording) in exchange for a higher rate for the life of the line; for its 1st-lien special promotion it “cannot pay your mortgage recording fees or mortgage transfer taxes.” | Primary residence; “co-ops, condominiums, and non-owner-occupied investment properties are not accepted”; membership tied to living, working, worshipping or attending school in NYC (or family/household of members) | https://www.nymcu.org/lending/home-equity-lending (2026-11-05) |
| Ridgewood Savings Bank | HELOC; also a lump-sum home equity loan | “HELOCs are variable rate products” (after an introductory year) | “No closing costs,” with its footnote: it “will pay the applicable mortgage tax and recording fees subject to reimbursement on early termination.” Also says no application, origination or annual fee. | Property types listed: 1–4 family homes, 1-family vacation homes, condos and co-ops (it must be first lien on co-ops) | https://www.ridgewoodbank.com/home/borrowing/home-equity (2026-11-05) |
Reading these claims: a lender paying the tax or closing costs is a promotion with conditions, usually a payback if you close the line early. It isn’t a tax exemption, and other lenders’ products differ.
Questions to settle before choosing
- Do I want to keep my current first mortgage, or replace it?
- Do I need the money at once, or over time?
- How would a variable rate and the jump to repayment affect me (HELOC)?
- What does the loan estimate or HELOC disclosure list for closing costs, and who pays the recording tax?
- If a lender covers costs, what do I owe back if I close or refinance early?
- For a co-op, does the lender even offer the product, and does the recording tax apply?
We don’t take applications, and nothing on this site checks whether you’d qualify. For how a HELOC’s draw and repayment periods work, see How a HELOC works in NYC.
Sources
Official sources, all read 2026-11-05:
- CFPB, What is a HELOC?: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-is-a-home-equity-line-of-credit-heloc-en-107/
- CFPB, Loans similar to a HELOC (cash-out refinance): https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-other-types-of-loans-are-similar-to-a-heloc-en-253/
- NYC DOF, Mortgage Recording Tax: https://www.nyc.gov/site/finance/property/property-mortgage-recording-tax-mrt.page
- NYC DOF, Statistical Profile of the NYC Mortgage Recording Tax (2024): https://www.nyc.gov/assets/finance/downloads/pdf/reports/reports_mrt/2024-mrt-report.pdf
- NYS Tax Department, Credit-line debt bulletin (updated March 30, 2026): https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/mrt/credit_line_debt.htm
- NYS Tax Department, TB-MR-580 (updated March 30, 2026): https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/mrt/multiple_obligations.htm
- NYS Tax Department, TSB-M-95(4)R (Sept. 8, 1995): https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/memos/mortgage/m95_4r.pdf
- NYC DOF, Real Property Transfer Tax: https://www.nyc.gov/site/finance/property/property-real-property-transfer-tax-rptt.page
Lender pages (marketing and disclosures, not law), all read 2026-11-05: listed in the table above.
This is research from public pages, not legal, tax or financial advice, and not a recommendation of any lender or product. Terms and rules change; the agencies’ and lenders’ own documents control.