Disclosurenyheloc.com is run by NH Assets. Not a lender or broker; no applications, no advertised rates; number-only estimates stay in your browser. No partners and no compensation from anyone; no paid placement. Not legal or financial advice. Details

NH Assets team · sources checked 2026-11-06

HELOC vs. home equity loan in NYC

Both let you borrow against the equity in your home, and both put a lien on it. The difference is how the money comes to you and how you pay it back. This page describes the two products from official sources. It isn’t a recommendation of either, and lenders’ own terms vary and change.

The difference, in CFPB’s words

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau puts it this way:

A home equity loan is a specific amount of money borrowed against the equity of your home. A Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) is a line of credit, like a credit card, except you are borrowing against the equity of your home.

And:

With a home equity loan, you receive the money you are borrowing in a lump sum payment, and you may have a fixed or adjustable interest rate. With a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC), you can borrow or draw money multiple times from an available maximum amount.

If you already have a mortgage, CFPB says both “would be considered second mortgages that you’d need to pay in addition to your first mortgage.”

Side by side

Home equity loan HELOC
How you get the money A lump sum, a specific amount (CFPB) Draw multiple times up to a maximum during the “draw period” (CFPB)
Borrowing again CFPB says you “typically borrow all the money up front” Paying down the balance replenishes available credit (CFPB)
Interest rate “May have a fixed or adjustable interest rate” (CFPB) “Usually have a variable interest rate” (CFPB); some let you convert part to fixed
Payments “Regular monthly payments” (CFPB) Vary with the balance; “often significantly higher once you enter repayment” (CFPB)
Lien A second mortgage if you already have one (CFPB) A second mortgage if you already have one (CFPB)

Sources: CFPB pages listed below, read 2026-11-06.

Things CFPB flags about HELOCs

  • The line can be frozen or cut. If your home’s value “decreases significantly,” or your finances change, the lender may stop letting you draw more.
  • Minimums and fees. Some plans require a minimum draw each time, a minimum balance or an initial draw, and lenders can charge fees. Ask.
  • Repayment. When the draw period ends you can’t borrow any more. In some cases, CFPB says, “you may have to pay back the whole amount you borrowed as soon as the repayment period begins.”
  • Your home is the collateral. “If you fall behind or can’t repay the loan on schedule, you could lose your home.”

For a home equity loan, CFPB notes that “repayment is often required when you sell your home.”

NY mortgage recording tax: how the rules read

Both products are usually secured by a mortgage, and NYC’s Department of Finance says “a tax is charged when mortgages for property in New York City are recorded.” The NYS Tax Department’s bulletins don’t use the words “HELOC” or “home equity loan.” They describe how the tax works for different kinds of recorded mortgage:

  • General rule. TB-MR-580: “The tax is based on the principal amount of debt or obligation that is secured, or that may be secured, by the mortgage when it is executed.”
  • Credit line mortgages. A credit line mortgage secures a series of advances, payments and re-advances up to a maximum principal amount stated in the mortgage. For one, “the mortgage recording tax is based on the maximum principal amount that may be secured by the mortgage.” For a revolving line, that maximum “is generally equal to… the credit limit” (TB-MR-580).
  • Later draws. Tax Law §253-b, as the Tax Department summarizes it, exempts certain advances and re-advances. That covers credit line mortgages on a one- to six-family owner-occupied home, among others. Once tax is paid on the maximum, no further tax is due on advances made to the original borrowers named in the mortgage. Additional tax is due if the maximum is increased.

What this page does not say: that a HELOC has no mortgage tax, or what any particular HELOC or home equity loan would owe. Whether a given loan’s recorded mortgage is a credit line mortgage, and whether the §253-b conditions are met, is fact-specific. A product called a HELOC isn’t automatically a credit line mortgage for tax purposes. A lender may also advertise that it pays the tax or charges none; that’s the lender’s offer, with its own conditions, not a tax rule. Ask the lender, the title company or a tax professional.

Rates. DOF’s 2024 MRT report lists combined state and city rates of 2.050% for mortgages under $500,000, 2.175% for residential mortgages of $500,000 or more, and 2.800% for commercial mortgages of $500,000 or more. The report also says mortgages on individual cooperative apartments don’t incur the tax. DOF recommends ACRIS’s “Calculate Taxes / Fees” tool for the actual amount.

Where it’s recorded. Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens record through ACRIS. Staten Island records in person at the Richmond County Clerk’s Office.

Questions to ask a lender

  • Is this a lump-sum loan or a line I can draw on? If a line, how long is the draw period, and what happens when it ends?
  • Is the rate fixed, adjustable or variable? Can part of a line be converted to fixed?
  • What fees are charged at closing and each year? Is there a minimum draw or balance?
  • How will the mortgage be recorded, and who pays the mortgage recording tax?
  • Can the line be frozen or reduced, and on what terms?

If you’re struggling with an existing mortgage, CFPB suggests talking to a HUD-approved housing counselor first: (855) 411-2372.

See also How a HELOC works in NYC and HELOC vs. cash-out refinance.

Sources

Read 2026-11-06 unless noted.

Product descriptions, not recommendations. Terms change. This is research, not legal, tax or financial advice.